Social Media
Crowdsourcing for B2B Marketing
I’ve been talking to people (anyone who’ll listen actually) about ‘crowdsourcing.’ They’ve listened to me, mostly, and then looked at me like I’m a twat. So I started to doubt my own visionary forward thinking brilliance and thought maybe I’d best just shut up and sit down. But then again, I’ve never been one to run from a stupidity contest so I thought I’d persevere. In years to come you can all look back and say, “That McKee bloke – genius.” Or, alternatively, “twat.”
Crowdsourcing is a term first attributed to Jeff Howe in 2006, a tech writer for the US magazine Wired. It broadly means using the power of many to solve problems. Rather than rely on a single person within an organisation or even an entire department, whole companies their clients and people you don’t even know can contribute to solving a particular corporate challenge. It’s all served up on the interweb via your website or chosen flavour of electronica (intranet/extranet/landing page/microsite/social media/forum…) and the corporate entity gathers opinion and content from far and wide. Think of the principal of opensource applications and you’re on the right lines. If thousands of developers around the world can freely contribute a little bit of code in their spare time, it doesn’t take long to produce an entirely open/free platform to challenge the likes of even Microsoft. The same principal can be applied to any challenge where many hands can make light work. It’s a bit of a big deal. One that the B2B marketing community has thus far almost wholly ignored.
I’m surprised at the limited adoption in the B2B space because I do believe I’m in love with the whole concept. Brand strategy formulation is all about gathering opinion and establishing a cohesive, compelling story that the audience will believe in. Brands aren’t about guidelines or products or services, they’re about feelings – how people feel about your brand. Rather than being restricted to the views of a few key stakeholders in a workshop and a couple of focus groups, what if you could open up the brand discussion to the people who really matter – the prospective customers – and have the whole world tell you how they feel? Well, actually, you can. How cool is that? And yet, when I offer the service to companies that I understand are seeking that very customer insight, I’m still being given the ‘twat’ look…
There are many fairly dull examples of crowdsourcing I could offer you, but that wouldn’t really inspire or excite. But by relaxing the definition slightly, I can perhaps demonstrate the power of Social Media to shape how companies can affect or be affected by how people ‘feel’ about their brand.
‘United Breaks Guitars’ started as a music video protest by Dave Carroll, a musician who had his guitar broken by United Airlines baggage handlers. United refused to pay for the broken guitar so Carroll wrote a song, produced a video and posted it to YouTube. Google it and enjoy the video. Then think about the Mashable report that the video was viewed three million times in its first ten days of release and almost doubled again ten days later. In the first 10 day period it generated 14,000 viewer comments. Not many of them were very complimentary about United. You can now download the song on iTunes. Dave Carroll was crowdsourcing – using a wider audience to gather opinion and influence brands (his and United’s).
Best Buy, the large U.S. retailer has been using internal crowdsourcing for over a year. Their ‘Company as Wiki’ YouTube video clearly articulates the benefit of empowering staff to contribute to management thinking and processes to improve the brand. A new idea for a store can be conceived by any staff member, posted to the Best Buy site for comment and discussion by other members of staff. The good ideas rise to the top and management are able to fund the best projects immediately. Best Buy is currently considering how to use crowdsourcing for its external audience.
So. I’m ready. Who wants to play? Genius or twat? Let the crowd decide…
Scot McKee
Managing Director
Birddog Ltd.
+44 (0)20 7323 6666

8 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
hide commentsCrowdsourcing in B2B marketing – sure… I’m also a believer that there’s gotta be something to this, but it’s difficult to nail down what would make sense to crowdsource. The obvious examples are logo, or naming designs – where a company puts out a brief, and waits for the results – then picks a winner; but they’re really a sub-type of the larger concept. I’m exploring crowdsourcing a new name for my personal blog…
http://andybryant.squarespace.com/blog/2009/8/9/crowdsourcing-a-new-name-for-this-site.html
Couldn’t we also consider viral video distribution as a sort of community crowdsourcing? The community is picking up your content, and spreading it far and wide… however generally they’re not re-mixing it.
There have to be some better examples here…
Andy.
Andy Bryant
12:19 14 August 2009
Take a look at Imaginatik (http://www.imaginatik.com/). Interesting company – interesting CEO too in Mark Turrell – and helping organisation’s tap into the collective creative thinking of their employees to solve specific issues.
But whichever way you do it, it’s got to be a good thing, right?
Mark
14:46 14 August 2009
Hi !
I strongly believe in the power of Crowdsourcing. However, it is crucial to note that crowdsourcing in order to get the most out of it is not a simple process. But I guess with the right resources and people in place it is a rather useful technique for research, development, gaining insights, etc…….in order to help your company to improve and nourish for the future and the long run.
The past has shown that big brands are already using internal as well as external crowdsourcing in order to further develop their businesses……hence more heads= more creativity.
Since your article focuses on B2B Crowdsourcing I thought this article “How B2B Brands Should Use Crowdsourcing” http://ow.ly/1JDOA might be interesting for you……
Let me know what you think
All the best,
Clarissa
Clarissa - blurGroup
16:42 11 May 2010
Thanks for the article Clarissa – I think you’re absolutely right. The challenge, for now, is to encourage the majority of the b2b market (predominantly smaller companies) to divert budgets from their traditional communications channels into (untried) crowdsourcing initiatives. To achieve that we need to give them quick, easy and value based solutions. Those solutions are available, as you say, but finding the brands willing to change is likely to remain difficult for a while yet. Keep going though – we’ll get there!
S
admin
10:24 12 May 2010
Firstly, so happy to have found you and your work, because there aren’t enough people like you just telling it like it is….
Secondly, you use the word “twat”
The latter interests me even more than the points you make about B2B Crowdsourcing (and yes, I am an advocate of that too) because I, for one, am SICK TO DEATH of so called social media or new media people spending all their time on Twitter/Facebook/LinkedIn talking to more so called social media people about how they think SM should work, how we should measure it, how we should do this, or that, or the other…..
If you are one of those so called “gurus” the answer is simple, and Birddog’s posts reiterate that….could you all please stop being TWATS yourselves and do us and our industry a favour and just get out of your egotistical box and DO THE WORK…..yes I’m going off track but hey, that’s how I roll.
Big Up Birddog for just simply telling it like it is
Jo Porritt
09:01 15 May 2010
Thank you Jo – welcome to our world. Good use of the ‘G’ word too. In parentheses as well, “gurus” – eww.
S x
admin
16:09 15 May 2010
I have organized and executed several B2B IT Collaboration hosted crowdsourcing leadgen events. Some get it others do NOT want to help anyone. Many do not feel comfortable sharing anything. Ironically 50% of sales reps have not made quota in 5 yrs (www.csoinsights.com) study and event budgets have been cut, BUT C levels prefer face to face LIVE events to meet suppliers and peers. So some reps bring 10 guests and others do zip!
Biggest offenders – the biggest companies! The smaller firms bring guests to share.
Collaboration and B2B crowdsourcing takes time to build trust and many will never feel comfortable.
(but others will and benefit)
regards,
Stuart (from Toronto)
Stuart
02:41 31 July 2010
Thanks Stuart – that’s an interesting perspective on ‘live’ crowdsourcing. I suspect we’re all more willing to share online where the stakes aren’t too high. Online crowdsourcing actually attracts those prepared to collaborate and avoids the ‘I’ll show you mine if you show me yours’ mentality. Good luck with your events.
Scot
Scot
11:08 3 August 2010